Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Soon Serving Spring

I finally had a chance to step beyond trivialities with the SpringSource dm Server.

To make things clear, this server is all about giving life to Spring Dynamic Modules (DM). Spring DM is not new but putting this technology in action was awkward: you had to deal with an embedded OSGI container and figure a lot of things out. The SpringSource dm Server provides an integrated no-nonsense environment where dynamic modules live a happy and fruitful life.

The benefits of dynamic modules are well known, and mostly derived from the OSGI architecture. The goodness Spring adds on OSGI is the clean model for service declaration and referencing. This is priceless as it enables a true highly cohesive and loosely coupled application architecture within a single JVM. If you come from a world of EJBs and troubled class loaders, this is the holy grail.

To exercise this sweet platform beyond the obvious, I have built the prototype of a JMS-driven application. The architecture was pretty simple: a bundle using Message Driven POJOs to consume a Sun OpenMQ destination, which then informs clients of new messages through a collection of listener service references. The idea was to allow the deployment of new clients or the hot replacement of a particular client at runtime. Verdict? It just works. The SpringSource dm Server goes to great length to isolate you from bundles going up and down (depending on the cardinality of your references to OSGI services, you may still get a "service non available" exception).

What I really enjoyed was the possibility to use bundles of Spring wired beans as first class citizen applications. Gone is the need for wrapping Spring in a web application to get a proper life cycle... POJOs rule!

Version RC2 of the server still has some rough edges (for example, the deployment order in the pickup directory is fuzzy and the logging messages are badly truncated and ill formatted) but they are minor compared to the amount of work done on the platform itself.

For me, the main challenge remains in making this server truly production-grade. Here are some points that I think need improvement:
  • Consoles all the way down: You have to juggle between the Web Admin Console, the Equinox OSGI console and JConsole to perform different bundle management operations. The SpringSource dm Server needs a single console to rule them all.

  • The configuration management is unclear: I ended up using an extra module, the Pax ConfigManager, to load external properties file in the OSGI Configuration Admin service. The SpringSource dm Server needs a default tool for this before going to production.

  • A proper service Shell script is missing: you just get a start and a stop script, which is not enough for production. A unique script with the classic start/restart/stop/status commands would be way better. If the matter of licensing was not such a hot subject in SpringSource currently, I would suggest them to use Tanuki's Wrapper as their boot script.
It is obvious that SpringSource will take this server to the next level and make it production ready pretty soon. It might already be done while I write this.

I you are a latecomer like me and have not started to seriously investigate this technology, now is the time.

No comments: